The Shocking claim by the Pakistani lawmaker Shandana Gulzar Khan, “more than 82% of rapists are fathers or brothers in Pakistan”
The Shocking claim that “more than 82% of rapists are fathers or brothers in Pakistan” stems from a 2020 statement by Pakistani lawmaker Shandana Gulzar Khan, citing data from the rights group War Against Rape (WAR). According to reports, she stated that over 82% of rape perpetrators are family members, including fathers, brothers, grandfathers, and uncles, with cases often coming to light when victims seek abortions.
However, this statistic is controversial and lacks robust, publicly available primary data to verify its accuracy. WAR’s figure may reflect specific case studies or underreported incidents, as many victims do not report due to social stigma or familial pressure, with mothers often avoiding police involvement.
No comprehensive, peer-reviewed study or official government data confirms this exact percentage across Pakistan. The claim has been amplified on social media, often with inflammatory rhetoric, but these posts are not reliable evidence.
Rape in Pakistan is a systemic issue, with low conviction rates (around 2%) and cultural factors like victim-blaming complicating justice. During the COVID-19 lockdown, reported sexual assaults reportedly surged by up to 400% due to increased indoor confinement with relatives.
The statistic, while shocking, should be approached cautiously due to potential sampling biases and lack of transparent methodology. Sexual violence in Pakistan is a serious issue, but precise numbers are hard to pin down given underreporting and societal taboos. For a deeper understanding, cross-referenced national surveys or NGO reports would be needed, but these are often incomplete.
Below, I provide a detailed breakdown of the issue, including context, challenges in verification, and broader insights into sexual violence in Pakistan.
Context of the Claim
● Source of the Statistic: The 82% figure was cited by WAR, as reported in a Wikipedia entry on “Rape in Pakistan,” which draws from a 2020 discussion involving Shandana Gulzar Khan. WAR’s data suggests that familial perpetrators dominate reported cases, with victims often remaining silent due to social stigma, and cases only coming to light during medical interventions like abortion requests.
● Social and Cultural Factors: In Pakistan, sexual violence is heavily underreported due to cultural taboos around sex and honor. Women and girls face significant barriers to reporting, including fear of retribution, victim-blaming, and pressure from families to avoid public disgrace. Mothers, in particular, may avoid reporting to protect family reputation, which contributes to the hidden nature of familial abuse.
● COVID-19 Impact: The Sustainable Social Development Organization noted a 400% surge in reported rapes and sexual assaults during Pakistan’s COVID-19 lockdown, attributed to increased confinement with relatives, which may exacerbate familial abuse. This aligns with the claim that family members are frequent perpetrators.
Challenges in Verifying the Statistic
● Lack of Primary Data: The 82% figure lacks a publicly available, peer-reviewed study or comprehensive dataset to substantiate it. WAR’s reports are not widely accessible, and the statistic may reflect a specific sample rather than a national trend. Without transparent methodology, it’s difficult to assess its reliability.
● Underreporting and Bias: Sexual violence in Pakistan is grossly underreported, with estimates suggesting only a fraction of cases reach authorities. For instance, Human Rights Watch reports a rape every two hours and a gang rape every eight, but these are based on reported cases, which are likely a small subset of actual incidents. Familial abuse, due to its private nature, is even less likely to be reported, potentially skewing data toward cases that reach medical or legal attention.
● Anecdotal Amplification: The statistic has been widely circulated on Social platforms, often with sensationalized or inflammatory framing, but these posts lack primary evidence and cannot be considered reliable. Such posts may reflect sentiment but do not substantiate the claim.
● Official Data Gaps: Pakistan’s National Police Bureau reported 14,456 rape cases from 2018–2021, with Punjab accounting for the majority (e.g., 3,883 of 4,326 cases in 2018). However, these figures do not break down perpetrator relationships, making it impossible to confirm the 82% claim using official statistics.
Broader Insights into Sexual Violence in Pakistan
● Scale of the Problem: Sexual violence is a pervasive issue in Pakistan, with significant societal and institutional challenges
● Frequency: Human Rights Watch estimates a rape occurs every two hours, and 70–90% of women experience some form of domestic violence.
● Child Sexual Abuse: NGO Sahil reported 2,227 child sexual abuse cases in the first half of 2023, averaging 12 children per day, with 47% involving children aged 6–15.
● Conviction Rates: Conviction rates for rape are abysmally low, ranging from 0.2% to 4% in various reports, discouraging victims from pursuing justice.
● Reported Cases: The Ministry of Human Rights noted a decline in reported rape cases from 4,326 in 2018 to 1,866 in 2021, but this may reflect underreporting rather than a true decrease.
● Familial Perpetrators: Studies consistently indicate that most sexual violence involves known perpetrators. A Lahore General Hospital study (2020–2022) found 77% of sexual assault cases involved a known perpetrator, though it didn’t specify familial ties. Globally, the UN and other sources estimate 70% of sexual assaults involve someone known to the victim, supporting the plausibility of high familial involvement in Pakistan’s context.
●Institutional Barriers: Police indifference and bias are well-documented. WAR reported in 1992 that 20% of 60 rape cases involved police officers, and in 2008, WAR members were assaulted while aiding a gang rape victim. Human Rights Watch notes that police often dismiss domestic violence as a “family matter,” and only 1.5% of police officers are female, limiting sensitive handling of cases.
● Legal Framework: Pakistan has enacted laws like the Anti-Rape Act 2021 and the Protection of Women’s Act 2006, establishing special courts and Anti-Rape Crisis Cells. However, implementation is weak, and cultural norms often override legal protections.
● Critical AnalysisPlausibility: The 82% figure is plausible given the high prevalence of known perpetrators globally and Pakistan’s specific context of patriarchal family structures and lockdown-related spikes in abuse. However, without a clear dataset, it may overstate or misrepresent the proportion of familial perpetrators.
● Alternative Data: Other sources provide related insights but don’t directly confirm the 82% claim:UNFPA Pakistan reports 28% of women aged 15–49 have experienced physical violence, and 6% have faced sexual violence, with 34% of ever-married women experiencing spousal violence.
A Karachi study (2005–2021) recorded 6,580 rape cases, but perpetrator relationships were not detailed.
Madadgaar Helpline reported 93% of women experience some form of sexual violence in public places, but familial abuse wasn’t quantified.
● Societal Implications: The focus on familial perpetrators risks oversimplifying a complex issue. Sexual violence in Pakistan spans familial, spousal, and stranger-perpetrated abuse, with systemic factors like low convictions, police corruption, and victim-blaming enabling all forms.
Bajinder Gets Life Imprisonment In Rape Case: April 2025
The 82% statistic highlights the severe issue of familial sexual violence in Pakistan but cannot be fully verified due to limited primary data and methodological opacity. Sexual violence remains a critical problem, with low reporting, minimal convictions, and cultural barriers exacerbating the crisis.
The claim underscores the need for better data collection, stronger legal enforcement, and societal shifts to address all forms of gender-based violence. For further details, WAR’s reports or national surveys like the Pakistan Demographic and Health Survey could provide additional context, though access to WAR’s specific data remains a challenge.